John married Louisa Sweetapple on 3 Jul 1871 in Buffalo, Erie, New York. Louisa (daughter of Charles Sweetapple and Sarah Lickman) was born on 7 Jun 1854 in Colden, Erie, New York; died on 15 Jun 1936 in Collins Center, Erie, New York; was buried on 18 Jun 1936 in Springville, Erie, New York. [Group Sheet]

1. Ada Lulu Vance was born on 21 Mar 1876 in North Collins, Erie, New York; died on 7 Jan 1963 in Lawtons, Erie, New York.
2. Grace Lilian Vance was born on 29 Dec 1877 in New York; died in 1924.
3. Leslie M. Vance was born on 4 Jun 1883 in New York; died in 1903.
4. Myrtle Evadne Vance was born on 1 Oct 1885 in Marshfield, Erie, New York; died on 9 Sep 1976 in Warsaw, Wyoming, New York.
5. Jane L. Vance was born in Jun 1896 in New York; died on 3 Jul 1978 in Tulare, California.